Marketing teams segment customers. They sort them into groups, decide which groups matter most and treat each group differently. Everyone in sales knows this, because the segments decide who they call.
Procurement teams do the same thing to their suppliers. They sort you into a box, and the box decides how you’ll be treated: who you get to meet, how often you’re put out to tender, and whether anyone will listen when you bring an idea. The first time I saw it, it blew my mind.
The tool most of them use is the Kraljic matrix. Every procurement director I’ve met has used it, or something very like it. If you sell to large organisations and you haven’t met it yet, this guide is for you. It explains the model properly, then turns it round to look at it from the supplier’s chair, with seven figures to try on your own accounts.
What is the Kraljic matrix?
A way of sorting everything a company buys into four boxes, so that each box can be bought in a different way.
It comes from Peter Kraljic, who was a director in the Düsseldorf office of McKinsey when he published Purchasing must become supply management in the Harvard Business Review in September 1983. His argument was that purchasing had become a routine, while supply itself had become risky. Scarce materials, political upheaval and fast-changing technology had, as he put it, “ended the days of no surprises”. A company needed to know which of its purchases could hurt it, and manage those differently from the paperclips.
So he asked two questions of every purchase. How much does it matter to our profit? And how risky is the supply? Two questions, each answered high or low, give four boxes.
Four boxes, four ways of being bought
More than forty years on, the Chartered Institute of Procurement and Supply still teaches it as a tool for identifying and reducing supply risk.
What do the two axes measure?
Profit impact is how much the purchase affects the buyer’s results. It’s usually judged by things like the volume bought, its share of total cost, and its effect on the quality of the buyer’s own product or on growth. A raw material that makes up a third of the cost of goods has a high profit impact. So does a small component that decides whether the finished product works.
Supply risk is how hard it would be to get the same thing somewhere else. It rises when there are few suppliers, when new ones find it hard to enter the market, when the technology is changing quickly, or when the item is scarce (Wikipedia).
Both axes are judged from the buyer’s side of the table, which matters. You may think your service is vital and unique. If the buyer thinks it’s a small line on the budget that three other firms could supply, that’s the box you’re in.
What does procurement do in each box?
Each box has a name and a playbook. The names vary a little between textbooks, and I’ve given the common alternatives. The tactics come from the standard descriptions by CIPS and Wikipedia, and from a consultants’ summary of the usual moves in each box.
Routine items: make it easy
Low profit impact, low supply risk. Also called non-critical items. Stationery, consumables, most maintenance supplies.
Nobody in procurement wants to spend time here, so the aim is efficiency: standard products, catalogues, purchasing cards, online ordering, and as few suppliers as possible. If you’re in this box you’ll rarely get a meeting, and you don’t need one. You win by being easy to buy from. The danger is consolidation, when twenty small suppliers are replaced by one large one.
Leverage items: use our buying power
High profit impact, low supply risk. The purchase matters a great deal, and there are plenty of suppliers who could provide it.
This is where the buyer holds the cards and plays them. CIPS describes it as the box where the buying company can use its full purchasing power, through tenders, target prices and substitute products. In practice that also means bundling volume, frequent re-bids and e-auctions. If you’re here you’ll know it. The conversation is about price, the contracts are short, and your contact is a buyer with a savings target. When people say they’ve been commoditised, this is the box they mean.
Bottleneck items: secure the supply
Low profit impact, high supply risk. A cheap part that only one or two firms make. A specialist service with a waiting list.
The buyer’s priority is to keep supply flowing: longer contracts, safety stock, and a great deal of patience with you. It can feel like a strong position, and for a while it is. But the playbook has a second half, which is to find an alternative. Procurement will be qualifying a second source, or asking engineers to change the specification so they no longer need you. A bottleneck supplier is being tolerated while the buyer works on a way out.
Strategic items: work together
High profit impact, high supply risk. Sometimes called critical items. The things the buyer’s own product depends on and can’t easily get elsewhere.
Here the textbook answer is partnership: long-term agreements, regular contact at senior level, shared plans, and close attention to how you’re doing as a business. CIPS calls it a balance of power, managed through performance-based partnerships. This is the box your key account team wants to be in. It comes with scrutiny as well as access, and one item on the buyer’s list that suppliers tend to forget: the make-or-buy question. A strategic purchase is one the buyer may decide to bring in-house.
One caution before you pick a box for yourself. Kraljic designed the matrix for purchases, and many companies use it for suppliers. The two aren’t the same. If you sell a customer three things, you may be strategic for one, leverage for another and routine for the third, so the useful question is about each thing you sell.
Try the four boxes on some invented suppliers.
Which box would procurement choose?
Why does this look so familiar?
Because it’s segmentation. Marketing sorts customers by what they need and what they’re worth, then decides which segments get the best people, the most attention and the keenest offers. Procurement sorts suppliers by profit impact and supply risk, then decides which ones get partnership and which ones get a tender.
The logic is identical. Neither department has the time to treat everyone as special, so each one works out who is special and saves its effort for them. If you’ve ever told a small customer that they’ll be served by the online portal from now on, you’ve done to them what a procurement team does to a routine supplier.
Two departments, one idea
Most sales teams know which segment their customers are in. Far fewer know which segment they are in themselves.
Why are sales and procurement pulling in opposite directions?
Because each is doing its job.
Your sales and key account team need to pull the account towards strategic. Strategic suppliers get longer contracts, access to senior people, and a hearing for new ideas. The procurement team will want to pull you towards commodity, for obvious reasons. Every alternative supplier they qualify, and every specification they standardise, lowers their risk and improves their hand at the next negotiation. That’s what the model tells them to do.
It helps to see this as a tug of war on the matrix. It isn’t personal, and it never stops.
The tug of war
Procurement pulls
Your team pulls
When I chaired the Key Account Management Forum’s winter conference at Cranfield in 2023, one of the speakers, talking about how procurement works, showed the room this matrix and asked the account managers to think about where they would put themselves on it.
Where has this customer put you?
You can make a good first estimate yourself. Answer six questions as the customer’s procurement team would, and be hard on yourself: the mistake everyone makes is to score from their own side of the table.
Score yourself as this customer sees you
If you sell this customer more than one thing, do it once for each. The answers are often different.
How do your customers look from your side?
The Kraljic matrix only looks one way. It says how the buyer sees the supplier, and nothing about how the supplier sees the buyer. That gap was filled in 1996 by Paul Steele and Brian Court, whose book Profitable Purchasing Strategies introduced supplier preferencing: a second matrix that sorts customers the way a supplier would.
Its two axes are how attractive the account is to you, and how much the business is worth to you. That gives four boxes again:
- Core. Attractive and valuable. You protect these customers and give them your best service.
- Development. Attractive, and not yet worth much. You invest to grow them.
- Exploitable. Valuable today and not very attractive. The supplier is tempted to push the price up and take what it can.
- Nuisance. Neither. You give them little attention and wouldn’t mind losing them.
If you’ve read the guide to key account planning, you’ll recognise this as a simpler cousin of the customer portfolio matrix.
Lay one model over the other and you get sixteen combinations, which is what CIPS teaches buyers to do. Some are comfortable: you’re strategic to them and they’re core to you. Some are dangerous, and the worst for a supplier is being a leverage item for a customer you treat as core, because you depend on them and they can replace you.
Their view of you, and yours of them
How they see you (Kraljic)
How you see them (supplier preferencing)
How do you move towards strategic?
There are two axes, so there are two ways to move.
Raise your impact on their profit. This is the vertical axis, and the work is to show what you’re worth in the customer’s own numbers: the cost you take out, the revenue you help them win, the risk you remove. That is what value-based selling is for. A supplier who can say “this saved you £400,000 last year, and here’s the calculation” is hard to file under routine. It also means talking to the people who feel the impact, in operations, finance and sales, as well as the people who place the order.
Become harder to replace, for good reasons. This is the horizontal axis, and it’s where suppliers go wrong. Supply risk goes up when what you do is rare: expertise competitors don’t have, a service level nobody else can match, knowledge of the customer’s business built up over years. Those are the same things that give any supplier power in Porter’s Five Forces.
Risk also goes up if you trap the customer, with a proprietary format, a contract that punishes leaving, or knowledge you refuse to write down. I’d avoid all of it. High risk without high impact puts you in the bottleneck box, and the job of procurement in that box is to get rid of you. The move that lasts is up and to the right together, with more value and more of what only you can do.
And accept that some accounts shouldn’t move. If what you sell that customer really is a routine item, the profitable answer is to be the easiest routine supplier they have, and to save your key account effort for somewhere it can work.
How do you track it across all your key accounts?
One account tells you a little. All of them together tell you a lot, so you should measure where you are for every key account, and do it again each year.
Put each account in the box you believe that customer has you in. Then look at where your revenue sits. A business with most of its revenue in the leverage box is one tender away from a bad year, however friendly the meetings are.
Plot your key accounts
The picture belongs in your account plans, next to the customer’s view of your strengths and weaknesses in the 9-box SWOT. Watch the direction as well as the position. An account that was strategic two years ago and is leverage today is telling you that someone on the other side has been doing their job.
Should you just ask procurement where you are?
Yes. Learn the model first, so that you can use their language, then ask them where you sit on it and what it would take to move.
They might tell you, they might not. Don’t ask, don’t get. Even a guarded answer tells you something, and the question itself shows you understand their job.
It works in the other direction too. One well-known procurement site advises buyers who want to know how a supplier sees them to ask the supplier directly. If they’re being told to ask you, you can certainly ask them.
Some questions that work:
- “When you segment your suppliers, which group are we in?”
- “Is that for everything we supply, or does it differ by product?”
- “What would a supplier in our position need to do to be seen as strategic?”
- “Where do you see the most risk in this category over the next three years?”
- “Who else in your business should we be talking to about that?”
What are the limits of the model?
It has been criticised for forty years, mostly by the people who use it.
- It doesn’t say how to move. Cees Gelderman and Arjan van Weele, who have studied how companies actually use the matrix, pointed out that it gives no guidance on moving an item or a supplier from one box to another. That’s a gap for buyers and an opening for you.
- The scores are judgements. There’s no agreed way to measure profit impact or supply risk, and where the lines are drawn decides the result. Two buyers in the same company can put you in different boxes.
- Spend gets used as a shortcut. Many teams use the amount they spend in place of profit impact, which pushes big, simple purchases up the chart and hides small ones that are critical to quality.
- It’s a snapshot. Supply markets change. A classification that was right three years ago may be wrong today, in either direction.
- It only looks one way. It ignores what the supplier wants, which is why supplier preferencing was added to it.
None of that makes it less important to you. A model can be imperfect and still be the one your customer is using.
Where should you start?
- Learn the four boxes well enough to explain them to your team in five minutes. Figure 1 is enough.
- Score your top five accounts as their procurement teams would, using Figure 5, one product line at a time.
- Plot them in Figure 7 and look at where the revenue sits.
- Pick one account to move and decide which axis you’re working on: more impact, more that only you can do, or both.
- Ask. At your next review meeting, ask procurement where they have you and what would change it.
Your customers have already put you in a box. Find out which one.
Sources: Kraljic, P. (1983) “Purchasing must become supply management”, Harvard Business Review, September; Chartered Institute of Procurement and Supply, Kraljic matrix and Supplier preferencing matrix, the latter adapted from Steele, P. and Court, B. (1996) Profitable Purchasing Strategies, McGraw-Hill; Wikipedia, Kraljic matrix, citing Gelderman, C.J. and van Weele, A.J. (2003) “Handling measurement issues and strategic directions in Kraljic’s purchasing portfolio model”, Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management, 9(5–6); Gelderman, C.J. and van Weele, A.J. (2002) “Strategic direction through purchasing portfolio management: a case study”, Journal of Supply Chain Management; Umbrex, Kraljic matrix; Art of Procurement, What exactly is the supplier preferencing model?.