For as long as I can remember, salespeople have been told to sell on value, not price. Very few have been told what that means in practice. When budgets tighten, price tends to win the argument, and the value conversation never quite happens.
One of the most useful pieces of research on the subject is “Three Ways to Sell Value in B2B Markets”, by Joona Keränen, Harri Terho and Antti Saurama, published in MIT Sloan Management Review in 2021 (volume 63, number 1). It draws on more than a decade of field research with over 70 B2B companies and more than a hundred interviews with senior decision-makers (author’s copy). Its main point is simple and useful: value-based selling isn’t one strategy. There are three, and they need very different things from the seller and the customer.
Here’s what the research says, as a set of questions and answers, with four figures to try.
What is value-based selling?
Selling on the money a customer gains from your offer, set against what they pay for it. The authors define it as demonstrating and documenting the monetary worth of the economic, technical, service and social benefits a customer receives in exchange for the price.
The reasoning is plain. In business markets, customers buy things to reduce their costs or increase their revenues. If you can show, in money, how much your offer does either, you give them a reason to pay more than the cheapest alternative.
What does it take?
The article lists four core capabilities, drawing on earlier work by James Anderson, Nirmalya Kumar and James Narus, and by Harri Terho and colleagues, among others:
- Understand the customer’s business model. Go beyond the needs they tell you about, to the value drivers that make a real difference to their profits.
- Build a quantified value proposition. Put a size on the value opportunity, compared with the customer’s next best alternative: what they do today, or a competitor’s offer.
- Prove you can deliver it. Usually through customer references, or guarantees that reduce the customer’s sense of risk.
- Check it happened. Monitor, verify and document that the promised value was realised.
The first capability is where the strategy tools come in. A customer’s Business Model Canvas, value chain and Five Forces tell you where their profits come from and where they’re under pressure, which is where your value has to land.
Why do so many companies struggle with it?
Because they treat it as one approach that works the same way everywhere. The authors found that confusion about what value salespeople are meant to sell, which outcomes they’re pricing, and which risks seller and buyer share, is behind many failed attempts. Companies that struggle tend to fall back on price-centric selling: competitive prices and product features, with no link to the value for the customer’s business.
What are the three ways to sell value?
Product-centric, customer process-centric and performance-centric. Each asks more of the seller and the customer than the one before, and each suits a different kind of buyer. The figure lays them out alongside price-centric selling, following the table in the article. Click any one.
One price-centric approach, three value-based ones
Less change, less riskMore value, more risk, more change for both sides
Product-centric. The easiest place to start for most manufacturers. You keep selling the product, but the pitch moves from features to benefits the customer can put a value on, and the price moves up to match. The customer still does the value creation; you provide a better resource for it. It works only with buyers who look at total cost of ownership, so you often need to reach people beyond purchasing, in production, operations or finance. Its weakness is imitation: a competitor can copy the product, so you have to keep investing in it.
Customer process-centric. Here you sell improvements to how the customer works, using your expertise in applying what you sell. Value is created together: you need the customer’s data, access to their processes, and their willingness to change them. Because it rests on expertise rather than product features, it’s harder to copy. The challenge comes later: once the customer’s process is better, you have to keep finding the next improvement to win the renewal.
Performance-centric. The most ambitious. You’re paid on results, such as availability, productivity or cost per unit, sometimes with gain-sharing or pain-sharing built in. It offers the greatest value and the highest margins, and the most risk, because you take responsibility for outcomes. You need enough control over the customer’s process to deliver them, and the customer has to be willing to hand some of it over. The authors note that only a few firms have mastered it, and that successful ones usually start small and widen the contract over time.
Can you tell them apart?
Seven pitches, based on examples in the article. Which approach is each one using?
Which approach is this?
How do you choose your approach?
The authors suggest four steps.
- Work out your strengths. Are they in superior products, in process expertise, or in managing customer processes for better outcomes? Put another way: can you deliver value in money through better products, better processes, or guaranteed results? A value chain analysis of your own business is a good way to answer this honestly.
- Find big value opportunities in your target markets. Look at what drives your customers’ profits: costs, revenues or capital tied up. The three approaches reach different parts of that. Better products usually only cut costs. Process support can also lift revenue. Taking over a process for a guaranteed result can free up the customer’s capital.
- Understand the changes each approach needs inside your company. Product-centric selling mostly needs a change of mindset in the sales team, supported by training, value calculators and incentives. Process-centric selling needs real consulting skills, which few product salespeople pick up easily, so companies often hire from their customers’ industries. Performance-centric selling needs structural change well beyond sales: joint teams, new contracts, and people on the customer’s site.
- Choose customers who can and will buy value. More on this below.
The article’s examples are worth knowing. Kemira, in a commoditised chemicals market, trained its sales and application managers to improve customers’ chemical processes, and over time moved into total chemical management. Hilti worked out that owning and maintaining power tools cost its customers far more than buying them, and moved from selling premium tools to managing tool fleets.
How do you put the value into money?
Compare the extra price you’re asking with the extra value the customer gets, against their next best alternative, over a sensible period. Change the numbers and see how the case holds up.
Does the value justify the premium?
A worksheet like this is only as good as the numbers in it, and the numbers only count if the customer believes them. The strongest value cases are built with the customer, from their data, and come with a plan for proving the value afterwards. That’s the fourth capability, and it’s the one most often skipped.
What does a value-based pitch sound like?
Take a software company selling project management tools. A feature pitch lists what the product does: task tracking, file sharing, team collaboration.
A value-based pitch starts from the customer’s situation. The salesperson has learned, by asking, that projects are running late and that the cost of each delay is significant. The pitch then connects the product to that problem, and puts a number on it that the customer helped build: for example, how many days of delay a year the tool could remove, and what those days are worth. The numbers come from the customer’s own records, and the pitch says how the result will be measured.
The difference is less about the words than the preparation. You can’t make a value-based pitch without understanding the customer’s business first.
Which customers are worth the effort?
Not all of them. Value-based selling costs more to do, and the cost to serve rises as you move towards the more complex approaches. So the authors recommend careful selection, based on whether customers are able and willing to buy value: do they understand total cost of ownership, is there someone who can claim value for the whole organisation rather than savings for purchasing, and can the buying team support the changes needed?
Successful vendors, they found, look at two things above all: the size of the value opportunity, and access to senior decision-makers. Move the sliders to place a customer.
Which customers to sell value to
The authors also warn of two common mistakes. The first is pushing an overly sophisticated approach too early, which is expensive for the seller and asks too much change of the customer. Starting small and building up works better. The second is chasing only customers who can afford a premium. Customers on tight budgets can be especially open to deals that ask little upfront and tie payment to the savings or revenue they actually get.
How does this fit with key account management?
Closely. Key accounts are usually the customers where the value opportunity is largest and where you have, or can build, access to senior people, the top-right of Figure 4. A key account plan is also where the first capability gets done properly: understanding the customer’s business, often with a 9-box SWOT of their strategy, before deciding which of their strategies you can help with.
The three approaches also give account plans a direction. A key account relationship might start product-centric, move to process improvements as trust grows, and in time reach shared performance targets. The authors observe that the capabilities build on each other, so starting simple makes the later steps easier.
Can AI help?
Yes, mainly with the groundwork. An AI assistant can summarise a customer’s annual report to find their value drivers, draft a first value calculator, or turn a feature list into a set of customer benefits for the team to test. It can also play a sceptical buyer, which is good practice for defending the numbers.
It can’t supply the customer’s data, or the customer’s agreement that the numbers are right. Those still come from the conversation.
Where should you start?
Pick one product and one customer segment. Write down, in money, what your product saves or earns a typical customer compared with their next best alternative, and check it with two or three of them. If the number survives, you have the start of a product-centric value proposition, and the foundation for everything that comes after it.
Sources: Keränen, J., Terho, H. and Saurama, A. (2021) “Three Ways to Sell Value in B2B Markets”, MIT Sloan Management Review, 63(1), pp. 64–70 (author’s final draft); Terho, H., Haas, A., Eggert, A. and Ulaga, W. (2012) “‘It’s almost like taking the sales out of selling’: towards a conceptualization of value-based selling in business markets”, Industrial Marketing Management, 41(1), pp. 174–185; Anderson, J.C., Kumar, N. and Narus, J.A. (2007) Value Merchants, Harvard Business School Press.